
Choosing between a heat pump vs furnace comes down to how each makes heat, what your home needs in a cold Ontario winter, and what you pay for gas and electricity. A heat pump also cools in summer, while a gas furnace delivers strong heat on the coldest days. This guide compares them fairly, and when you’re ready, see our heat pump installation page.
Key takeaways
- A heat pump moves heat and also cools. A gas furnace burns fuel to make heat.
- Running costs depend on the price of gas and electricity, and on how well the home is sealed.
- Cold-climate heat pumps are built to keep heating in winter, but sizing matters.
- Many homes keep the furnace as backup in a dual-fuel setup.
- A load calculation, not a rule of thumb, shows what your home needs.
Last updated . Written and reviewed by the Assurance HVAC Heating & Cooling service team.
On this page
- Heat pump vs furnace: how each one heats
- Heat pump vs furnace side by side
- Heat pump vs furnace running costs
- Heat pump vs furnace in cold weather
- Comfort and air temperature: heat pump or furnace
- What each system needs from your home
- Why many homes keep the furnace: dual-fuel
- Safety: furnace combustion and heat pump electrical
- Rebates for choosing a heat pump
- Should you replace a working furnace with a heat pump?
- How to decide between a heat pump and a furnace
- Heat pump vs furnace: common questions
Heat pump vs furnace: how each one heats
A furnace creates heat by burning natural gas in a sealed combustion chamber and sending that heat through the ducts. A heat pump doesn’t burn anything. It uses electricity to move heat from outdoor air into the house, and in summer it reverses and moves heat out, so one system heats and cools.
That difference drives most of the rest of the comparison: efficiency, running cost, safety, how each performs in extreme cold, and what your electrical panel and gas line must support.
Heat pump vs furnace side by side
The two systems trade strengths. A heat pump is very efficient in mild and moderate cold and replaces your air conditioner. A gas furnace puts out strong heat regardless of how cold it gets. The table summarises where each one tends to come out ahead for a typical GTA home.
| Topic | Heat pump | Gas furnace |
|---|---|---|
| Energy source | Electricity | Natural gas |
| Cooling | Yes, in the same unit | No, needs a separate air conditioner |
| Heat on the coldest days | Falls with the cold, so backup may help | Steady, unaffected by outdoor temperature |
| Air from the vents | Warm, around body temperature plus a little | Hot |
| Typical lifespan | About 15 years | 15 to 20 years |
| Efficiency measure | HSPF2 for heating, SEER2 for cooling | AFUE |
| Combustion safety | No flame, no flue, no gas | Needs venting, a CO alarm and gas safety |
| Electrical needs | Often needs panel capacity checked | Light electrical load |
Heat pump vs furnace running costs
Running cost depends on the price of electricity and gas, how well the house is insulated, and how efficient each system is. A heat pump can deliver more heat than the energy it draws, so it often costs less to run in mild cold. A furnace can come out ahead in the deepest cold, when a heat pump slows down.
Because rates change, we don’t quote figures here. We price both options for your home, and the flat-rate price for any work is approved before it begins.
Heat pump vs furnace in cold weather
A heat pump’s output drops as the outdoor temperature falls, because there’s less heat in the air to pull in. Cold-climate models are designed by their makers to keep heating at much lower temperatures than older units, and a backup source covers the rest. A furnace’s output doesn’t change with the weather.
That makes sizing important in a GTA home. See our cold-climate heat pumps guide for what to look for, and note that defrost cycles and some backup heat are normal in winter.
Comfort and air temperature: heat pump or furnace
Furnace air is hot and arrives in strong bursts, so the house heats quickly and cycles on and off. A heat pump, especially a variable-speed one, runs longer at a lower output, so the air is gentler and the temperature stays more even. Some people read that as cooler air, even when the house is perfectly warm.
A variable-speed heat pump or a ductless mini-split can also heat and cool rooms more evenly than a single-stage unit. Ductwork condition matters for either choice.
What each system needs from your home
A furnace needs a gas line, venting, a condensate drain if it is high-efficiency, and combustion air. A heat pump needs an outdoor pad or bracket, a refrigerant line set, a drain path, and enough electrical capacity, so the panel is part of the check. Ducted heat pumps use your existing ducts if they suit the airflow.
Homes without ducts can use a ductless mini-split, which needs only a small hole through the wall for each indoor head.
- Furnace: gas supply, venting, combustion air, condensate drain
- Ducted heat pump: ducts sized for the airflow, outdoor pad, panel capacity
- Ductless mini-split: a wall hole and mounting for each head, outdoor unit, panel capacity
- Either one: a load calculation to size it to the home’s heat loss
Why many homes keep the furnace: dual-fuel
You don’t have to pick one. A dual-fuel, or hybrid, system pairs a heat pump with a gas furnace. The heat pump handles mild and moderate cold, and the furnace takes over below a set switchover temperature. You get cooling, efficient heat most of the winter and strong heat on the coldest nights.
Our dual-fuel heat pump guide explains how the switchover is set. It also helps when your furnace is mid-life and a full change isn’t needed yet.
Safety: furnace combustion and heat pump electrical
A gas furnace needs venting and working carbon monoxide alarms: Ontario requires one next to every sleeping area and, since January 1, 2026, on every storey of a home with a fuel-burning appliance, a fireplace or an attached garage. A heat pump has no flame or flue, so it carries no combustion risk, though it needs correct electrical work. If you keep a furnace, the usual gas rules apply.
- Gas smell: leave the home without switches or phones, then call Enbridge Gas at 1-866-763-5427 from outside.
- CO alarm sounding: get everyone, pets included, outside and call 911.
- Never open electrical panels or burner compartments yourself.
The Ontario carbon monoxide safety page (opens in a new tab) explains alarm placement.
Rebates for choosing a heat pump
Ontario’s Home Renovation Savings Program, delivered with Save on Energy and Enbridge Gas, supports some heat pump upgrades. Eligibility and amounts depend on your home and your current heating fuel, and programs change, so we don’t quote figures. Our rebates page links the official program page.
Check eligibility before you sign anything, and ask the installer how the paperwork works.
Should you replace a working furnace with a heat pump?
If your furnace works and is mid-life, you usually don’t need to rush. Adding a heat pump alongside it keeps a backup, and replacing at the end of life is the natural time to choose. A furnace past 15 to 20 years, or one with a cracked heat exchanger, is worth replacing and comparing options.
Read our repair or replace a furnace guide first. For heat pump faults after you switch, our heat pump repair in Richmond Hill page covers what we fix.
How to decide between a heat pump and a furnace
Start with the house, not the equipment. A load calculation shows how much heat the home loses at design temperature, and your bills show what you pay now. Then compare options for cooling, comfort, cost and backup, and decide whether one system, or both, suits you.
A technician can lay out each option, and you approve a flat-rate price before any work. For help with sizing, use ENERGY STAR Canada (opens in a new tab) to read about efficient models.
Heat pump vs furnace: common questions
Is a heat pump better than a furnace?
It depends on the home. A heat pump heats efficiently in mild cold and cools in summer, so it can replace your air conditioner too. A gas furnace gives steady, strong heat in extreme cold. Many GTA homes get the best of both with a dual-fuel setup. A load calculation shows which suits yours.
Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a furnace?
Often in mild and moderate cold, because it moves heat rather than burning fuel. In deep cold the gap narrows, and it depends on your gas and electricity rates. Rates change, so compare your own bills with a quote for each option before you decide.
Can a heat pump heat my whole house in a GTA winter?
A properly sized cold-climate heat pump can heat many homes through a GTA winter, and makers design them to keep heating well below freezing. The home’s insulation, ducts and sizing matter, and some homes keep backup heat for the coldest nights. A heat-loss calculation tells you.
Do I still need a furnace if I have a heat pump?
Not always. Some homes run on a cold-climate heat pump with electric backup. Others keep a gas furnace as the backup in a dual-fuel system, which uses the furnace below a set outdoor temperature. Which is better depends on your home, your panel and your energy costs.
Can a heat pump use my existing ductwork?
Often yes, if the ducts are sized for the airflow a heat pump needs. Heat pumps move more air at lower temperatures than furnaces, so undersized or leaky ducts can limit comfort. A technician checks the ductwork during the assessment. Homes without ducts can use a ductless mini-split.
Is a heat pump safer than a gas furnace?
A heat pump has no flame, flue or gas line, so it carries no combustion risk or carbon monoxide source of its own. A properly maintained furnace is also safe, with CO alarms next to the sleeping areas and on every storey, as Ontario requires in homes with a fuel-burning appliance, a fireplace or an attached garage. Either needs correct installation by a certified technician.
How long does a heat pump last compared with a furnace?
A heat pump lasts about 15 years, while a gas furnace commonly lasts 15 to 20. Care matters more than the label: regular filter changes, tune-ups and clear outdoor units help either one reach the top of its range. A heat pump also runs year-round, which adds wear.
Who can advise on a heat pump or a furnace in the GTA?
Assurance HVAC Heating & Cooling installs and repairs both across Toronto, North York, Richmond Hill, Vaughan, Markham, Mississauga and Oakville, with TSSA-certified gas technicians and 313A-certified AC mechanics. You approve a flat-rate price before work starts, and all major brands are serviced.
Planning a replacement? We’ll call you back to book a quote visit.
Send the form or call. You’ll get a confirmed arrival window and a price before any work starts.
Open 24/7, with technicians out day or night for no-heat and no-cooling emergencies
